AdvertiseDonate
Friday, November 20, 2026Local news for Lake County, Illinois.
Lake County IL Gazette · 100 South Saunders Road, Suite 150, Lake Forest, IL 60045
Politics · Houston

Landlords choose eviction judges in Texas

Rice University research reveals wide disparities in ruling rates between judges serving the same Harris County precinct.

By Rafael Delgado ·

Illustration for: Landlords choose eviction judges in Texas
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

Landlords filing eviction suits in Harris County, Texas, currently select which judge hears their case, a practice that creates measurable differences in legal outcomes for tenants. A new study from Rice University's Kinder Institute indicates this selection process allows property owners to influence the probability of a successful judgment.

Researchers analyzed more than 320,000 eviction cases filed between 2019 and 2024. The data shows that within each Justice of the Peace precinct, two elected judges preside over separate courts. Steve Sherman, a Kinder Institute researcher, noted that these judges often produce distinct results despite serving the same geographic area. "We did find that within each precinct, across those two judges, you could have very different rates of judgments in favor of the landlords or the tenants or dismissals," Sherman said.

The disparity in rulings is substantial. In some instances, the gap in judgments favoring landlords exceeded 12 percentage points between the two judges in a single precinct. Sherman explained that the property owner or manager determines which court receives the filing. "The property owner, the property manager who files the eviction suit, gets to choose which of those two judges in the precinct the case goes to," he said. This ability to choose a judge exists even when the number of cases assigned to each judge varies widely within the same district.

The study suggests that tenants may face better odds if they contest the initial ruling. Sherman stated that appeals frequently result in more favorable final judgments for the tenant side. "Appeals generally do work out for the tenant," Sherman said. "They do have a higher rate of final judgments in their favor." The researchers recommended assigning cases randomly between the two judges in each precinct to mitigate the current imbalance.

The findings come from an analysis of eviction records spanning five years. The Kinder Institute team could not identify the specific reasons for the diverging judgment rates but noted the structural advantage granted to landlords by the current selection method. The report calls for procedural changes to ensure consistent handling of eviction claims across Harris County courts.

More Politics · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get Lake County IL Gazette in your inboxLocal news for Lake County, Illinois. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Get Lake County IL Gazette in your inboxLocal news for Lake County, Illinois. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.